Is there interest for using different routing services within one route? Some parts of route calculated with Kurviger and some parts of route calculated with BRouter profiles.

Origin of the discussion: [image] Offroad routing Route planning Heiko, mir ist schon klar, dass BRouter das kann: [2020-12-01 07_23_57-BRouter Web Client] Aber dann muss ich in den Flugmodus gehen und offline navigieren, was zur Folge hat, dass die gesamte Tour BRouter…

I think the app already offers so many options that it is getting harder and harder configure it correctly. A “switch” may help to ignore blocked roads.

Use of different routing services within one route already works in offline rerouting: [image] App: Partial offline rerouting Implemented features During normal navigation a rerouting is done only up to the next waypoint, when you leave the route. This is great, because …

Trouble with Brouter (and other) is not providing manual designed straight line connections. So the Locus “in app” planner has manual routing mode between consecutive *Shape points. [Draw manually] Manual design so not necessarily have to be just one straightforward single line . You can make i…

[image] Hampic: A “switch” may help to ignore blocked roads. But such a switch applies to the entire route - I would rather be able to draw a point-to-point line (without navigation, just as a “route missed” part) where I think it makes sense. Different routing services would complicate thin…

[image] zaphod_42: I would rather be able to draw a point-to-point line (without navigation, just as a “route missed” part) where I think it makes sense. That will be implemented with the following features: (one of the profiles can be the straight line) [image] App: Multip…

[image] zaphod_42: I would rather be able to draw a point-to-point line Hallo Wolfgang. Anyway be carefull, you have to make sure that it somewhat corresponds with what you will actually be driving, to avoid generating an out of track(route) alert. [image] 0709: Manual design so not nece…

[image] devemux86: Some parts of route calculated with Kurviger and some parts of route calculated with BRouter profiles. yes absolutely, nice idea, but also a mix of Kurviger routing options would be great, for example section 1 quickest route, section 2 curvy route, section 3 extra curvy ro…

Nevertheless, the proposal further tested by combining Kurviger and offline B-router test drives. In the end it does not seem very attractive, it all becomes quite complex and the results sometimes confusing. It is comparable to a marriage. Cheating and having it both ways may be adventurous, but t…

Hallo, aus meiner Sicht wäre es doch am besten, wenn die App immer mit dem Kurviger-Algorithmus arbeitet. Mit B-Router hatte ich im Offline-Routen noch keine guten Ergebnisse. Selbst einfache Strecken wollten mir nicht gelingen. Und unterwegs die Route schnell mal offline an die örtlichen Begebenhe…

Use of different routing services within one route

Discussion App

devemux86 December 1, 2020, 8:59am 2

Origin of the discussion: