Car shuttles motorrail or similar

Kurviger can already navigate through car shuttle trains. The most well-known example is the English Channel.
However, I have a question about the following example:

Kurviger avoids navigating via the Böckstein-Mallnitz car shuttle train.
This is presumably due to a missing OSM tag. But which one?
I’ve also looked at examples that do work, but couldn’t find anything.
Surely someone here knows more :slight_smile:

P.S. Yes, I know you can make the section a straight line, but only if you know the route

How about this? I’ve set up a via point (SP). It also works if I place the via point (SP) on the ramp for the motorail train.

So it’s because of this “potential closure”?
Because there’s a barrier?
And you tried going from north to south, it doesn’t work at all, even with a waypoint on the tracks.
So somehow it’s got to work without those weird workarounds.
If you fix the OSM data, probably yes.

Edit: it only goes in one direction because Kurviger also recognizes the northern access as a private driveway

ok, I changed the entrances and exits from Driveway (private driveway) to Service Road. Let’s see if that helps.

Kurviger avoids private driveways, which is correct. Only the ramp access roads are not driveways

That won’t help, you should revert that. Highway was already set to service, and service was driveway. You can wait a day or two, but I would be very surprised.

The barrier is right in the middle of the path, and I think that’s why the whole path has a potential closure and it needs to be forced using targeted SPs.


When reversing the route, set them to entry and exit accordingly.


To the ferry experts: It should be similar there, so set targeted SPs? I could be completely off base here..

The change in the screenshot is mine. I looked at other car shuttles, the access roads are always service roads. And as I wrote before, a driveway is a private access road, usually to a residential house or office. And at the barriers, it also says Access: Motorvehicles true. So I’m pretty sure now that changing from driveway to service road will help. I’ll report back in a few days when kurviger has pulled new data.

Spot on. :+1:

Kurviger apparently really assumes private access for service=driveway (according to the OSM wiki, no default is actually intended, but in practice most driveways seem to lack an access tag, so this is practical). The company’s website describes which vehicles are allowed and which are not. Access tags probably would have worked too. Just as an add-on, it saves a lot of time. Definitely interesting for some.

I also think that a driveway should not be interpreted directly by Kurviger as access:private.
And I believe (not sure) that wasn’t always the case either.
I can imagine that if a driveway has no access tags, it is estimated as private by krvg..?
Perhaps someone from the team can explain the logic here?

ps. found this as well :slight_smile: keyword “access:designated as default”