New Export | Neuer Export

@Steffen - „Es sieht dann so aus, als hätte man einen Track importiert.“ - leider nur “hätte.”

Die ‘BMW Motorrad Connected’ App, war mal ein Versuch Wert
kommt aber mit Track-GPX nicht zurecht.

Vielleicht liegt es auch an den verschiedenen Karten Here <> OSM.

Oft sind Straßen gesperrt die eigentlich befahrbar sind, genau so bei offroad Straßen.

Ein Track-GPX fährt einfach 1:1 und man entscheidet selber ob man fährt oder vorher kontrolliert.

Luftlinie ist für kurze Abschnitte OK aber für längere Abschnitte zu ungenau.

Der Track-GPX-Overlay von Kurviger wäre mit Abbiegehinweisen und Sprachansagen auch wünschenswert.

Die BMW App verbindet die Stützpunkte nicht mit Beelines, sondern führt eine “reguläre” Routenberechnung anhand der eingestellten Routenoptionen durch, und zeigt dann den berechneten Track an.
Wenn man gerne mit einem Track navigiert, kann das also durchaus Sinn machen.


44 + 2 BMW-Wegpunkte


51 + 2 BMW-Stützpunkte

2 Likes

Hallo, vielen Dank für den Tip, funktioniert wieder einwandfrei.

Gruß Otto

Exactly, BC import, however not at all costs. I am one of the users that uses direct export to the XT without Basecamp (which is becoming obsolete anyway…. Thank you for all the hard work making XT exports possible!

1 Like

Export XT2 pse check. (I do not own any Garmin gps btw).

  • The Kurviger XT2 export is rejected into Garmin Basecamp.

AdventurousLevel is not present in the TripExtensionsv1_schema ?

  • Deleting trp:AdventurousLevel allows the gpx file import.

Schema’s:

Schema.
https://logiqx.github.io/gpx-ideas/garmin/TripExtensionsv1.xsd
Files to test.
Bareldonk_XT2_export.gpx (7.1 KB)
Bareldonk_importable.gpx (7.0 KB)

Garmin BaseCamp software seems to be incompatible with Garmin XT2 navigation device.

Check the export with Microsoft XML Notepad.
The gpx file export is not valid.
Failure in the Garmin trp extension.

In xml notepad menu tab edit select Go to line.

Basecamp is extremely strict and rejects gpx files that do not comply with the topografix gpx schema and the Garmin extension schemas.

I did some more research into this strange issue.
https://zumouserforums.co.uk/viewtopic.php?t=3447
OMG! (Oh My Garmin)
“look a little deeper into the zumo XT2 functionality, it makes more frustration than pleasure”

It is remarkable that Garmin, which has always been so strict in the past, does not respect its own GPX extension. I will have a further look in it. Not valid gpx seems to be very “un-Garmin”.

The GPX export refers to <trp:ViaPoint><trp:AdventurousLevel>, which is missing in the Garmin TripExtensionsV1.xsd.
Therefore, either the GPX export or the XSD is incorrect.

Technically this is correct. Basecamp does not understand TripExtensionsV2. Therefore we use V1, similarly to Garmins own software Garmin Explore which is the reference app for the Zumo XT2. If you compare the exports of Explore to our exports they are quite similar, Kurviger has more features though :wink:

We just work with what is available at Garmin and try to find the best compromise. If there is anything new at Garmin, please let us know and we are happy to revisit our export. I don’t have access to the XT2 anymore, so I can’t do any new tests anymore, but we did test a lot of different devices before we decided for the current schema.

Hmmm, interesting.

I took this file

changed TripExtensions/v1 to TripExtensions/v2 and imported it into BaseCamp without an issue.

Does somebody have the TripExtensionsV2.xsd, I cannot find it?

Adventure tours exported from the Tread App cannot be imported into BaseCamp - Page 2 - Zumo User Forums

1 Like

Thanks. :+1:

AdventurousLevel is in TripExtensionsv2 but not in TripExtensionsv1. So V1 with AdventurousLevel would not be correct, I guess.

Question is if XT2 accepts V2, as it is explicitely the export for XT2.

To clarify, Basecamp can read the file but doesn’t understand the tags like Shapingpoints.

@Toffel
Tripextensions_v2.zip (1.6 KB)

1 Like

@boldtrn
According to the attached file, Basecamp does recognize the shaping point. What is not recognized during import in Basecamp is that it concerns the Motorcycling mode. AnywayI can’t see more since I only have Openfietsmap installed. What is most important is how the XT2 sees all this, of course. Only someone with a device can judge this.
Bareldonk_XT2_export_v2_valid.gpx (8.2 KB)

Correction. You are right. At the export it is than shown as a via point.

1 Like

Ahhh, ok.
Right - with V2 BC doesn’t recognise the motorcycle profile and treats SPs as VPs. That’s crazy.

1 Like

Gibt es dazu was neues ?

Aktuell gibt es dazu nichts Neues.